Integrating Film and Theater into My Classroom
On the rare occasions I do show a movie, it’s usually something very compatible with a novel we just read, such as “Speak” or “Frankenstein.” In those cases, I try to find a movie that is very close to the reading, if it’s possible. If not, I take what I can get and use it as a springboard for why the novel is so much better than the movie.
For the most part, when using a video, I don’t have the students do too much with it because we already spent a month reading and dissecting the corresponding literature. It’s almost like a rewarding break from “hard work.” I don’t let the movie watchers go completely work free, though. There has to be some accountability. If not, I’ve found they sleep, talk, text-message, etc. Then, there’s really no point to showing the movie. Usually I just have the students write an informal reaction to the movie and how it differed from the reading. Sometimes we do a great discussion afterwards about what parts were different and whether that was a good or bad move by the director. Typically, though, my students voice their disgust during the movie so there’s not much to say afterwards.
I have tried going to the theater with my students, as opposed to watching a film, and as much as I hate to say it, it was a waste of money for most of the students. It was something new and I would never regret giving them an opportunity they would never have had otherwise, but their blatant disrespect for what they don’t understand is eye-opening. It’s out of their comfort zone so they don’t appreciate it. For the students surrounding me, like on our trip to the Guthrie to see Hamlet, I was able to talk with them quietly and consistently about what was going on. Those students understood it and so they enjoyed it. However, the ones who couldn’t or didn’t want to hear me, did not have the same reactions. What did I learn from that? My students will only benefit from theater if I can consistently reiterate what is going on, like I do when we’re reading and comprehending literature. If I can’t do that for them, they are either unwilling or unable to do that for themselves. On one last note, this does not apply to all my students. I do have some very motivated, capable students. They’re just few and far between when it comes to theater.


